Chase vs Amex: Which Points Ecosystem Should You Build?
Two ecosystems, both excellent
Chase Ultimate Rewards and Amex Membership Rewards are the heavyweight transferable-points currencies, each worth roughly 2 cents a point when transferred to airline and hotel partners. You cannot go wrong with either, so the real questions are which partners you want, which perks you will use, and the order you open them in. Compare the full lineups on the Chase ecosystem and Amex ecosystem pages.
Where Chase wins
Chase has three big edges. First, it is one of only two currencies that reach World of Hyatt, the most valuable hotel program, which Amex cannot touch. Second, the Sapphire cards carry strong trip protections and a solid travel portal. Third, the Freedom cards add category bonuses that pool into one balance, the classic trifecta. The catch is the 5/24 rule: Chase declines you once you have opened five cards in 24 months, so open your Chase cards first, before you fill those slots elsewhere.
Where Amex wins
Amex counters with the widest transfer network in the business, more than 20 airline and hotel partners, including ANA, Delta, and others Chase does not have, which is gold for finding premium-cabin award space. The Amex Gold is one of the best everyday earners ever made, and the Platinum stacks lifestyle and travel credits that can offset its fee. Amex has no 5/24 limit, but it has its own rules: each bonus is once per lifetime, and the family rule means you should open Green, then Gold, then Platinum in order.
Which to build first
For most people the answer is Chase first, then Amex. Because Chase 5/24 counts cards from every issuer, you want to grab the Chase cards, and the Hyatt access and Sapphire protections, while you are still under five new accounts. Once your Chase setup is in place, layer on Amex for its transfer breadth and premium credits, where 5/24 does not apply. See Ultimate Rewards versus Membership Rewards for the deeper partner comparison.