When to Use Cash Instead of Points

The short answer: Use points when they beat about 1 cent each in value and you have a trip in mind; pay cash when the redemption is worth less than that, when the cash price is cheap, or when you would rather keep flexible points. Points are a depreciating currency, so a good redemption now usually beats hoarding.

The cents-per-point test

Divide the cash price of the booking by the points it would cost. If you are getting well over 1 cent per point, redeeming is a good deal; if you are getting less than about 1 cent, pay cash and keep your points. Cardocrat values every point at a flat 1 cent precisely so you can run this test honestly.

When cash wins

Pay cash for cheap flights and hotels, where redeeming burns a lot of points for little value, and when you have no travel planned, since flexible points are more valuable kept in the bank than locked into a low-value redemption. Also pay cash if redeeming would leave you just short of a better award you actually want.

When points win

Use points for expensive cash fares, especially premium cabins and high-season hotels, where transferable points booked through the right partner can be worth several cents each. That is the upside the 1-cent floor does not capture, and it is where the game pays off. See how points work.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to pay with points or cash?
Use points when you get more than about 1 cent of value each and have a trip planned; pay cash when the redemption is worth less than that or the cash price is low. Run the cents-per-point test.
Should I save my points or use them?
Generally use them on a good redemption rather than hoarding, because points are a depreciating currency that programs can devalue without notice. Earn toward a goal and redeem.

Related reading

Bryce Casson

Bryce Casson, Founder of Cardocrat. Every card is ranked by what it actually returns, with all points valued at a flat 1 cent and offers verified against issuer sources. About the author.